Why Public Problems Resist Simple Solutions

Indian civic worker coordinates several field teams in a winter air-pollution operations room.
2 min read

Part 1 of 7 in Righteously Wicked: How to Solve the Problems Nobody Owns

This chapter explains why North India's air pollution returns each winter despite familiar headlines and blame. It introduces Roshan Shankar's approach to recognising the shape of public problems and working on them step by step.

Quick Summary

  • North India faces recurring severe air pollution every November.
  • Public discussion repeatedly blames farmers, firecrackers, cars, or geography.
  • The smog lifts when winds pick up, and attention fades until the next winter.
  • Roshan Shankar compares the cycle to Sisyphus pushing a boulder uphill.
  • Recognising the shape of a public problem can make step-by-step work possible.

Roshan Shankar's playbook for public problem solving, with North India's air as the test case

Based on a presentation by Roshan Shankar, Director, Saroja Sustainable Solutions

Every November, North India chokes. Every November, we get the same headlines and the same blame game: farmers, firecrackers, cars, geography. Then the winds pick up, the smog lifts, and everyone forgets until next winter. Roshan Shankar has a perfect image for this. Sisyphus. The boulder rolls back down every winter.

Most of us look at this and decide it's hopeless, or that it's somebody else's job. Roshan's presentation, "Righteously Wicked Public Problem Solving," makes a more useful argument: problems like this have a recognisable shape, and once you see the shape, you can work on them step by step.

Frequently asked questions

Why does North India’s air pollution become a problem every November?

Every November, North India chokes, and the same headlines and blame game return. When the winds pick up, the smog lifts and attention fades until the next winter.

Who gets blamed for North India’s air pollution?

The recurring blame focuses on farmers, firecrackers, cars, and geography.

What does Sisyphus have to do with North India’s air pollution?

Roshan Shankar uses Sisyphus as an image for the recurring cycle: the boulder rolls back down every winter.

What is Roshan Shankar’s approach to public problems?

His presentation argues that public problems have a recognisable shape. Seeing that shape makes it possible to work on them step by step.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *