
Part 2 of 7 in Righteously Wicked: How to Solve the Problems Nobody Owns← Part 1Part 3 →
This chapter uses a series of remixes of an xkcd comic to show how academic disciplines are ranked and connected. It helps readers see why public problems cross disciplinary borders and why some people support everyone else.
- An xkcd comic lines up sciences by purity, from sociologists to mathematicians.
- Remixes place philosophers, epistemologists, farmers, and a turtle outside or beneath the original line.
- Public problems ignore borders between disciplines.
- People at the bottom carry everyone else, including farmers.
Roshan opens with a classic xkcd comic that lines up the sciences by "purity," from sociologists at one end to smug mathematicians at the other.
Then come the remixes. A philosopher waves from outside the box. Epistemologists hold the whole line up, farmers hold them up, and under everyone sits a turtle.
It's a joke, but the point lands. Public problems ignore the borders between disciplines, and the people at the bottom carry everyone else. Remember the farmers. They show up again.
Comic: xkcd.com/435, "Purity", by Randall Munroe (CC BY-NC 2.5). The remixes are after that comic; remix authors unknown.
Frequently asked questions
What is the xkcd comic about?
The comic lines up the sciences by purity, from sociologists at one end to mathematicians at the other.
What do the remixes add to the xkcd comic?
They place a philosopher outside the box, epistemologists holding up the line, farmers holding them up, and a turtle underneath everyone.
Why do public problems cross academic disciplines?
Public problems ignore the borders between disciplines.
Why are farmers mentioned in the chapter?
Farmers appear beneath the other groups and carry everyone else. The chapter says to remember them because they show up again.